Which COVID Vaccine is Best for Seniors? blog post on AskSAMIE.com

Which COVID Vaccine is Best for Seniors?

Which COVID Vaccine is Best for Seniors?

As we age, our immune systems naturally weaken, making older adults more susceptible to severe illness from infections like COVID-19. Choosing the right COVID-19 vaccine is crucial for maintaining health and independence, especially for those aiming to age in place. Here, we'll explore the available COVID-19 vaccines and by laying out the facts you'll have the information you need to talk with your doctor about the best  one for you.

Available COVID-19 Vaccines

Several COVID-19 vaccines have been authorized for emergency use or fully approved by health authorities. The main vaccines available in the U.S. include:

  1. Pfizer-BioNTech (Comirnaty)
  2. Moderna (Spikevax)
  3. Johnson & Johnson (Janssen)
  4. Novavax

Pfizer-BioNTech (Comirnaty)


  • Type: mRNA vaccine
  • Doses: Initially two doses, followed by booster doses
  • Efficacy: Approximately 95% effective in preventing symptomatic COVID-19 after the second dose

Pros for Seniors:

  • Strong Efficacy: Offers high protection against severe illness, hospitalization, and death.
  • Booster Availability: Regularly updated booster shots available to counter new variants.
  • Safety Profile: Extensive data from large-scale studies and real-world use demonstrate a strong safety record.

Moderna (Spikevax)


  • Type: mRNA vaccine
  • Doses: Initially two doses, followed by booster doses
  • Efficacy: Approximately 94% effective in preventing symptomatic COVID-19 after the second dose

Pros for Seniors:

  • High Efficacy: Similar to Pfizer, it offers robust protection against severe disease.
  • Durable Immunity: Some studies suggest longer-lasting immunity compared to other vaccines.
  • Booster Updates: Boosters are available and updated to address emerging variants.

Johnson & Johnson (Janssen)


  • Type: Viral vector vaccine
  • Doses: Single dose, with booster options available
  • Efficacy: Approximately 66% effective in preventing moderate to severe COVID-19, higher efficacy in preventing severe illness

Pros for Seniors:

  • Single Dose: Convenient for those who may have difficulty accessing healthcare facilities.
  • Strong Protection: Provides good protection against severe disease and hospitalization.
  • Booster Option: Boosters are available to enhance protection.


  • Lower Efficacy: Slightly lower overall efficacy compared to mRNA vaccines.
  • Safety Concerns: Rare cases of blood clots have been reported, though the benefits outweigh the risks.



  • Type: Protein subunit vaccine
  • Doses: Two doses
  • Efficacy: Around 90% effective in preventing symptomatic COVID-19

Pros for Seniors:

  • Traditional Technology: Uses a more traditional vaccine technology, which may appeal to those hesitant about mRNA vaccines.
  • Strong Protection: High efficacy in preventing severe disease.


  • Less Data: Less real-world data compared to Pfizer and Moderna.

Which Vaccine is Best for Seniors?

Considerations for Choosing a Vaccine:

  1. Efficacy: Pfizer and Moderna vaccines have shown the highest efficacy rates in clinical trials and real-world studies, making them strong options for seniors.
  2. Booster Availability: Regular boosters are crucial for maintaining immunity. Pfizer and Moderna offer updated boosters to address new variants.
  3. Safety: All approved vaccines have been shown to be safe. However, mRNA vaccines (Pfizer and Moderna) have the most extensive safety data.
  4. Convenience: Johnson & Johnson’s single-dose vaccine may be suitable for those with limited access to healthcare services, though boosters are recommended.


For seniors, the Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna vaccines are generally considered the best options due to their high efficacy, strong safety profiles, and the availability of updated boosters. However, the best choice can vary based on individual health conditions, accessibility, and personal preferences. So it's important that you talk with your provider about it to get the best, most tailored advice.

Staying Up to Date with Vaccines: Staying up to date with all recommended vaccines from COVID-19 to pneumonia to RSV, is crucial for protecting your health and independence. Regular vaccinations help prevent severe illness, reduce hospitalizations, and support your ability to age in place safely. For more on vaccines for older adults check out the resources at the National Institute on Aging.

In my practice, I have seen the significant benefits that vaccines provide in maintaining health and preventing complications. For personalized advice and to ensure you are receiving the best protection, consult with your healthcare provider. To learn more about considerations for aging in place visit AskSAMIE.com.

Stay proactive about your health and keep your vaccinations current to enjoy your golden years to the fullest.

Back to blog

Brandy Archie, OTD, OTR/L, CLIPP

Dr. Archie received her doctorate in occupational therapy from Creighton University. She is a certified Living in Place Professional with past certifications in low vision therapy, brain injury and driving rehabilitation.  Dr. Archie has over 15 years of experience in home health and elder focused practice settings which led her to start AskSAMIE, a curated marketplace to make aging in place possible for anyone, anywhere! Answer some questions about the problems the person is having and then a personalized cart of adaptive equipment and resources is provided.

She's a wife, mother of 3 and a die-hard Kansas City Chiefs fan! Connect with her on Linked In or by email anytime.

Want more helpful articles?

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter with helpful hints for caring for a loved one, new problem solving products and discounts on services you need!